Failure Analysis
Huobi's death was a slow-motion regulatory strangulation combined with strategic paralysis. The mechanics unfolded in three phases: (1) **Regulatory Guillotine (2017-2021)**: China's government systematically...
Huobi China \China
Huobi China was one of the world's largest cryptocurrency exchanges, founded in 2013 during the first Bitcoin boom. It provided a platform for trading digital assets, offering spot trading, derivatives, staking, and lending services. The value proposition was to be the dominant gateway for Chinese retail and institutional investors to access global crypto markets. Timing seemed perfect as China had 80%+ of global Bitcoin trading volume in 2013-2017. Huobi capitalized on regulatory arbitrage, low fees, and deep liquidity to become a top-3 global exchange by volume. However, the business was fundamentally built on regulatory tolerance that evaporated. China's escalating crackdown on crypto—from ICO bans (2017) to mining bans (2021) to complete trading prohibition (2021-2024)—destroyed the domestic market. Huobi attempted international expansion and rebranding (HTX), but faced intense competition from Binance, Coinbase, and newer DEXs. The core issue: a $300M+ funded centralized exchange couldn't pivot fast enough when its primary market became illegal, and its international operations lacked differentiation in an oversaturated, low-margin business.
Discover the reason behind the shutdown and the market before & today
Market Analysis
The cryptocurrency exchange market today is a tale of two worlds: compliant, institutionalized markets in the West and decentralized, permissionless alternatives globally. In the...
Startup Learnings
**Regulatory Risk is Existential, Not Operational**: Huobi treated Chinese regulatory risk as a 'manageable headwind' rather than an existential threat. Modern founders must stress-test...
Market Potential
The global cryptocurrency market has exploded from ~$10B (2013) to $2.5T+ peak (2021) and stabilized around $1.5-2T today. Daily spot trading volume exceeds $100B...
Difficulty
Building a compliant, secure cryptocurrency exchange in 2013 required custom matching engines, cold storage infrastructure, KYC/AML systems, and multi-jurisdiction legal frameworks—all bleeding-edge. Today, the...
Scalability
Crypto exchanges have excellent scalability economics once operational: marginal cost per trade approaches zero, network effects create liquidity moats, and trading fees (0.1-0.5%) generate...
Rebuild & monetization strategy: Resurrect the company
Execution Plan
Phase 2
**Step 2 - Validation (Months 7-12)**: Add decentralized trading via 0x or 1inch integration—users can swap USDC for BTC, ETH, or local stablecoins (e.g., cREAL in Brazil) directly in-app with 0.3% fees. Launch a USDC savings account (5-8% APY via Aave/Compound) to capture idle balances. Expand to 2-3 additional markets (Kenya, Philippines, Mexico). Secure a preliminary license in Singapore or UAE (6-12 month process) to establish regulatory credibility. Target 50,000 users, $50M in trading volume, and $500K in monthly revenue. Key metric: 20%+ of users trade weekly, 40%+ hold savings balances.
Phase 3
**Step 3 - Growth (Months 13-24)**: Launch crypto-to-fiat debit cards (Visa/Mastercard partnership via Marqeta) allowing users to spend USDC at 50M+ merchants globally. Introduce social trading features (copy-trading, leaderboards, referral rewards) to drive viral growth. Expand to 10+ markets across Africa, Latin America, and Southeast Asia. Invest heavily in local influencer marketing, community building, and educational content (crypto literacy is low in these regions). Secure Series A funding ($20-30M) to accelerate licensing, partnerships, and team scaling. Target 500,000 users, $500M in annual trading volume, and $5M in monthly revenue. Key metric: CAC <$20, LTV >$200 (10x payback).
Phase 4
**Step 4 - Moat (Months 25-36)**: Build proprietary infrastructure to reduce reliance on third-party providers: in-house KYC (cheaper, faster), direct banking partnerships (lower fiat fees), and a custom DEX aggregator (better execution, lower slippage). Launch a token (MRD) for governance and fee discounts (Binance BNB model)—users stake MRD to reduce trading fees from 0.3% to 0.1%, creating a flywheel (more users → more MRD demand → higher token value → more users). Introduce B2B services: white-label exchange infrastructure for local fintechs, API access for developers, and institutional custody for African/LatAm funds. Expand to 20+ markets and secure Tier-1 licenses (MiCA in EU, MSB in US). Target 2M users, $2B in annual trading volume, and $20M in monthly revenue at 40% net margins. Key metric: 50%+ of revenue from non-trading sources (cards, savings, B2B), proving business model diversification.
Monetization Strategy
Meridian's revenue model is diversified across five streams: (1) **Trading Fees (40% of revenue)**: 0.3% fee on all crypto-to-crypto swaps, split 0.2% to Meridian and 0.1% to liquidity providers. At $2B annual volume, this generates $6M annually. Users holding MRD tokens get discounted fees (0.1%), creating token demand. (2) **Fiat On/Off-Ramp Fees (30% of revenue)**: 1-2% fee on fiat-to-crypto conversions (e.g., NGN to USDC, BRL to USDC). At $500M annual fiat volume, this generates $7.5M annually. Costs include payment processor fees (0.5-1%) and banking relationships, yielding 50-60% gross margins. (3) **Savings Account Spreads (15% of revenue)**: Users deposit USDC into savings accounts earning 5-8% APY (via Aave/Compound). Meridian earns 8-12% on DeFi protocols and pays users 5-8%, capturing a 3-4% spread. At $100M in average savings balances, this generates $3-4M annually with near-zero marginal cost. (4) **Debit Card Interchange (10% of revenue)**: Visa/Mastercard pay 1-2% interchange fees on card transactions. At $200M annual card spend, this generates $2-4M annually. Costs include card issuance ($5/card) and fraud monitoring, yielding 40-50% gross margins. (5) **B2B Services (5% of revenue)**: White-label exchange infrastructure ($50K setup + $5K/month), API access ($500/month per developer), and institutional custody (0.5% AUM annually). At 20 B2B clients, this generates $1-2M annually with 70%+ gross margins. **Total Year 3 Revenue**: $20M annually at 40% net margins ($8M profit). **Unit Economics**: CAC $20 (local influencer marketing, referral bonuses), LTV $200 (2 years average user lifespan, $100/year in fees), 10x payback. **Scaling Path**: At 10M users and $10B annual volume (Year 5), revenue reaches $100M+ with 50%+ net margins, positioning Meridian as a $1B+ valuation company and a viable exit target for Coinbase, Binance, or Visa.
Related Startup Failures
BLOCKCHAIN/CRYPTO
15
Zebec
\USA
$35.0M
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
Real-time salary streaming on Solana blockchain, enabling continuous wage payments instead of monthly cycles.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Built payroll infrastructure for a crypto-native employment market that didn't exist; regulatory uncertainty killed enterprise adoption.
Rise
2021
Fall
2025
BLOCKCHAIN/CRYPTO
9
Qredo
\UK
$95.0M
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
Decentralized MPC custody for institutions to secure crypto assets without private keys, enabling instant settlement.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Entered saturated custody market late, burned cash on complex tech during crypto winter with frozen enterprise demand.
Rise
2018
Fall
2024
BLOCKCHAIN/CRYPTO
56
Bitspark
\China
$68K
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
Western Union for the blockchain age—1% fees and instant settlement for migrant workers using Bitcoin as the backbone.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Built a regulated financial institution on seed funding, then regulators turned hostile and COVID killed their cash agent network.
Rise
2014
Fall
2020
Disclaimer: This entry is an AI-assisted summary and analysis derived from publicly available sources only (news, founder statements, funding data, etc.). It represents patterns, opinions, and interpretations for educational purposes—not verified facts, accusations, or professional advice. AI can contain errors or ‘hallucinations’; all content is human-reviewed but provided ‘as is’ with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or reliability. We disclaim all liability for reliance on or use of this information. If you are a representative of this company and believe any information is inaccurate or wish to request a correction, please click the Disclaimer button to submit a request.