Failure Analysis
Qraved died from the classic marketplace death spiral: unsustainable unit economics meeting platform commoditization. The core issue was that restaurant reservations in Southeast Asia...
Qraved \Indonesia
Qraved was Southeast Asia's ambitious answer to Yelp and OpenTable, launching in 2013 as a restaurant discovery and reservation platform targeting Indonesia's emerging middle class. The value proposition was compelling: aggregate user reviews, professional food critic content, high-quality photography, and integrated table booking in a region where dining out was becoming a status symbol and social media ritual. The 'why now' was Indonesia's smartphone penetration explosion (2013-2016), rising disposable incomes, and a fragmented restaurant industry with zero digital presence. Qraved positioned itself as the authoritative voice for Jakarta's dining scene, combining editorial credibility with UGC and transactional utility. They expanded to Singapore and Bangkok, raised $15M from credible VCs (MDI, Gobi), and built a brand synonymous with foodie culture. The platform featured reservation management, loyalty programs, curated lists, and even attempted restaurant analytics dashboards. However, they were building a two-sided marketplace in a low-margin, high-CAC environment where restaurants viewed online presence as 'nice-to-have' rather than essential, and consumers had zero switching costs between discovery platforms.
Discover the reason behind the shutdown and the market before & today
Market Analysis
The restaurant discovery and reservation market in Southeast Asia today is dominated by three forces: Google Maps (free discovery with 90%+ market penetration), super-apps...
Startup Learnings
Marketplaces in emerging markets require 10x better unit economics than developed markets due to lower transaction values, higher CAC, and payment friction. Qraved's $15-30...
Market Potential
In 2013, Indonesia's restaurant reservation market was nascent—TAM appeared massive (270M population, growing middle class, dining out as aspiration). However, the *addressable* market was...
Difficulty
In 2013, building Qraved required custom backend infrastructure for reservations, manual restaurant onboarding, content management systems, mobile apps for iOS/Android, payment gateway integrations, and...
Scalability
Qraved's scalability was fundamentally constrained by marketplace dynamics requiring linear growth on both sides. Each new city meant rebuilding supply (restaurant partnerships requiring feet-on-the-street...
Rebuild & monetization strategy: Resurrect the company
Execution Plan
Phase 2
Week 3-4: Launch WhatsApp AI concierge (GPT-4 + Langchain) with simple NLP: 'I want Italian food in Orchard for 4 people on Friday at 7pm' → query Supabase for availability → return 3 options with photos/menus → confirm booking → send SMS confirmation. Test with 50 beta users (friends, food bloggers, corporate concierge services). Measure: booking completion rate, AI accuracy, user satisfaction.
Phase 3
Week 5-8: Add personalization layer using Pinecone vector DB to store user preferences (past bookings, cuisine likes/dislikes, dietary restrictions, spending patterns). Fine-tune prompts so AI remembers 'Sarah is vegetarian, prefers outdoor seating, celebrates anniversaries at French restaurants.' Expand to 30 restaurants. Launch referral program: diners get $20 credit for each friend who books, restaurants get free marketing. Target: 200 bookings/month, $15K GMV.
Phase 4
Month 3-6: Introduce SaaS tier for restaurants ($99/month base + $199/month premium with marketing automation and customer analytics). Build self-serve onboarding flow so restaurants can sign up, connect their POS (Toast, Square integration via Zapier), and go live in 24 hours. Launch corporate dining feature: integrate with Expensify/Brex for automatic expense reporting, target finance teams at tech companies (Shopee, Grab, Sea Group employees). Add voice booking via Twilio voice API for older demographics. Expand to 100 restaurants, 2,000 active users, $50K MRR ($30K SaaS + $20K transaction fees). Raise $500K-1M seed round from Sequoia Scout or Antler.
Phase 5
Month 7-12: Build moat through data network effects—AI gets smarter with each booking, learning neighborhood preferences, peak times, and pairing recommendations (wine, dishes). Launch 'Maître Insider' premium subscription ($15/month) offering priority reservations at top restaurants, exclusive chef's table access, and AI-curated monthly dining plans. Partner with Amex/Visa for co-branded dining rewards. Expand to Bangkok (50 restaurants) and Hong Kong (30 restaurants). Target: 500 restaurants, 20K active users, $200K MRR, path to $3M ARR. Series A readiness: prove 80%+ gross margin on SaaS, 40% net revenue retention, and AI-driven customer acquisition (organic WhatsApp sharing, SEO from AI-generated neighborhood dining guides).
Monetization Strategy
Three-tier revenue model: (1) SaaS subscriptions for restaurants—$99/month Starter (basic reservation management, 100 bookings/month), $199/month Pro (unlimited bookings, customer CRM, marketing automation, analytics), $499/month Enterprise (multi-location, API access, white-label AI concierge). Target 500 restaurants at $150 average = $75K MRR. (2) Transaction fees—5% on bookings over $100/person (premium dining), 2% on corporate dining bookings (higher volume, lower margin). At $500K monthly GMV, 3% blended take rate = $15K MRR. (3) Consumer subscription—$15/month 'Maître Insider' for priority access, exclusive reservations, and AI-curated dining plans. Target 2,000 subscribers = $30K MRR. Total: $120K MRR ($1.44M ARR) at 12 months, scaling to $10M ARR by Year 3 with regional expansion. Gross margins: 85% on SaaS (hosting costs $5K/month), 60% on transaction fees (payment processing + customer support), 90% on consumer subscriptions. The AI layer reduces CAC (organic WhatsApp sharing, SEO from content) and increases LTV (personalization creates habit). Exit strategy: acquisition by Grab/Gojek (distribution play), Stripe (vertical SaaS expansion), or OpenTable/Resy (geographic expansion into Asia). Comparable: Resy sold to Amex for $70M at ~3x revenue; SevenRooms (restaurant CRM) raised $150M at $1B valuation. The AI-native angle and B2B SaaS model make this fundable and defensible in a way Qraved never was.
Related Startup Failures
SAAS (B2C)
49
MySee
\China
$2.0M
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
P2P video streaming platform aiming to be China's YouTube, leveraging peer-to-peer tech to solve bandwidth costs in early broadband era.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Ran out of cash competing against better-funded rivals (Youku, Tudou) in a bandwidth-intensive market requiring massive scale and content deals.
Rise
2004
Fall
2007
SAAS (B2C)
36
Modsy
\USA
$72.7M
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
AI-powered 3D room visualization that let homeowners see furniture in their space before buying, with shoppable designs from major retailers.
CAUSE OF DEATH
High CAC, low repeat rates, and expensive human-in-the-loop design process prevented path to profitability despite strong product-market fit.
Rise
2015
Fall
2022
SAAS (B2C)
395
Kuaibo (Qvod)
\China
$50.0M
THE VALUE PROPOSITION
P2P video streaming that let 300M Chinese users watch HD content instantly—just don't ask where they got those movies.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Built a $50M business on 'we're just neutral tech' while 80% of traffic was pirated content and porn in increasingly authoritarian China.
Rise
2007
Fall
2014
Disclaimer: This entry is an AI-assisted summary and analysis derived from publicly available sources only (news, founder statements, funding data, etc.). It represents patterns, opinions, and interpretations for educational purposes—not verified facts, accusations, or professional advice. AI can contain errors or ‘hallucinations’; all content is human-reviewed but provided ‘as is’ with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or reliability. We disclaim all liability for reliance on or use of this information. If you are a representative of this company and believe any information is inaccurate or wish to request a correction, please click the Disclaimer button to submit a request.